American Family is ranked 10th in U.S. News analysis, with low scores in most subcategories, but competitive rates for high-risk drivers.
AAA
AAA is a newcomer in the Best Car Insurance Companies rating, tied with Progressive for 8th place, with below-average scores but high renewal rates and premiums.
Progressive
Travelers moved up two spots to tie for No. 6 position. No. 1 for Claims Handling and No. 3 for Most Likely to Be Renewed. Above-average policy renewal and affordable premiums.
Travelers
Travelers moved up two spots to tie at No.6, excelling in claims handling and policy renewal, offering below-average premiums.
Allstate
Allstate ranked No. 6 in Best Car Insurance Companies, No. 4 in Most Likely to Be Recommended, despite high rates.
Geico
Geico is ranked as the third best car insurance company of 2023 with average scores and second for affordable rates.
Nationwide
Nationwide ranks third with high scores in customer loyalty and recommendations, but below-average rates for some drivers, especially those with good driving or poor credit.
Farmers
Farmers ranks highly in customer service and claims handling, but falls short in customer loyalty and renewal rates, with higher than average rates.
State Farm
State Farm ranks second in our rating, excelling in Claims Handling, Customer Loyalty and offering low average premiums for high-risk drivers.
USAA
USAA ranked as top insurance provider in customer satisfaction and affordability, with eligibility only for military community members.